Although eggs are a popular ingredient in ice cream, this simple Nutella ice cream recipe doesn’t have any. Growing up, homemade ice cream, almost always vanilla (I can’t seem to recall any other flavor) was one of the best parts of summer. Pretty much you consume Nutella with a spoon, but it’s more fun in ice cream. How to make Nutella ice cream without eggs. I remember the big wooden ice cream maker my Dad used to make … So if you don't have Nutella in the house (or don't like it) you could simply ditch the Nutella and use a teaspoon of vanilla extract. And it's easily adaptable for other flavours of ice cream. For an extra dose of Nutella, serve your chocolate ice cream with Nutella Espresso Hot Fudge Sauce on top. Topped with Nutella of course, Nutella Ice Cream Sundaes!